February 18, 2016
sponsored by Tavant
ISSN 1550-9214         

HP's Warranty Accounting:

Before the split, HP's warranty expenses were declining for multiple years. After the split, the laptop and printer company has much higher warranty expenses than the server and storage company.

In the next four weeks, most of the major players in the U.S. product warranty business are going to file their annual reports for 2015, revealing their total sales an their warranty expenses for the year gone by. But because Hewlett-Packard Company ended its fiscal year in October, its annual report is already out. And because it split itself in half, there are actually now two separate annual reports that we need to examine.

Actually, because of the timing of the spin-off, we can examine both the final year of the old parent company as well as the first two years of the offspring. And we can compare the three entities in terms of claims paid, accruals made, warranty reserves held, and the expense rates of each.

Let's start with a look at the parent -- the computer manufacturer founded in a garage in 1935 by Bill Hewlett and Dave Packard. Back then the company made test equipment, and later branched out into electronic calculators, printers, copiers, fax machines, and eventually personal computers, minicomputers, and servers.

This company changed its name to HP Inc. at the conclusion of its fiscal year ended October 31, 2015, spinning off the server line of business into a new company called Hewlett Packard Enterprise Co., and keeping its printer and PC lines of business.

Warranty Expense Totals

In Figures 1 through 4, we're going to pretend that rather than changing its name to HP Inc. and shrinking through the spin-off, that it was an intact HP Co. that made its last financial report for the year ending Oct. 31, 2015. That way, we can complete a set of charts that documents the company's warranty expenses from fiscal 2003 until last year.

Figure 1 contains 52 data points for the company's warranty claims cost per quarter during those 13 years. As the company has pointed out numerous times, not all of these totals are actual cash payments. Some of it is indirect costs such as a percentage of call center expenses that goes towards warranty work, or payments in kind of one sort or another to channel partners, repair organizations, and suppliers.


Figure 1
HP Company's Product Warranties
Claims Paid per Quarter, 2003 to 2015
(in Millions of U.S. Dollars)

Figure 1


What this chart clearly shows is that HP's warranty claims cost has been declining. Back in fiscal 2008, the company spent more than $3 billion on claims in a single year for the first and only time in its history, with a peak quarterly outlay of $779 million just for the months of February, March, and April 2008. But at the time, its product revenue was almost $91.7 billion, so it was a manageable percentage of that total being spent on warranty claims.

By the time HP Co. became HP Inc. late last year, the quarterly claims total was down to $414 million, and the annual outlay was down to $1.7 billion. That's to be expected, given that computer hardware and printer sales were also declining for all those intervening years. And in fact, the warranty expenses were declining faster than sales, reflecting a more efficient warranty management system and less warranty spending per product sold.

Warranty Accruals

In Figure 2 we're tracking the quarterly accruals made by HP Co. over the 13 years from 2003 to 2015. Once again, 2008 marks the peak and 2015 is the trough, though the rise and fall for this warranty metric over the years hasn't been as smooth as it was for warranty claims payments. The highest outlay of them all was the $860 million accrued in the second quarter of fiscal 2008 and the lowest was the $361 million accrued in the second quarter of fiscal 2015.


Figure 2
HP Company's Product Warranties
Accruals Made per Quarter, 2003 to 2015
(in Millions of U.S. Dollars)

Figure 2


The highest yearly accrual total was $3.35 billion in fiscal 2008 and the lowest was $1.51 billion in fiscal 2015. In other words, accruals hit both higher highs and lower lows than claims did, reflecting how claims are spread out over the life of the products under warranty while accruals are concentrated at the time a product is sold.

Warranty Reserves

With the addition of accruals made and the removal of claims paid, the balance in HP's warranty reserve also rose and fell over the last 13 years. In Figure 3, we're looking at the ending balance in the company's warranty reserve for the last 52 quarters, from fiscal 2003 to 2015.


Figure 3
HP Company's Product Warranties
Reserves Held per Quarter, 2003 to 2015
(in Millions of U.S. Dollars)

Figure 3


Once again, the highest balance came in 2008 and the lowest was seen last year. It briefly exceeded $2.6 billion in October 2008 and dipped to $1.7 billion in October 2015 -- a change of more than $900 million.

For all 13 years, HP Co. simply segmented its net revenue into products, services, and financing income. To calculate the company's claims and accrual rates, we used just the product revenue in the bottom of our fraction. For instance, in fiscal 2014 the company reported $1.93 billion in claims paid, $1.84 billion in accruals made, and $73.7 billion in product revenue, resulting in a claims rate of 2.6% and an accrual rate of 2.5%.

Warranty Expense Rates

In Figure 4, we've taken the claims and accrual data from Figures 1 and 2 and divided them by the corresponding product revenue totals, to get twin lines of 52 data points for HP's claims and accrual rates. Because these percentage rates are the result of a comparison with product sales, they rise and fall at a different pace from the expenses themselves. For instance, the peak rates for both metrics came early in the period rather than in 2008, though the lowest rates did in fact come in fiscal 2015, when sales, claims, and accruals all bottomed out together.


Figure 4
HP Company's Product Warranties
Claims Paid & Accruals Made as a
Percentage of Product Revenue, 2003 to 2015
(in Percent)

Figure 4


As was mentioned, all of this data is now merely historical, because HP Co. has been split in two and changed its name. Hewlett Packard Enterprise Co. (HPE) has been spun off, and HP Inc. is the new name of the remainder of the old parent company.

Separating the Offspring

When HP Inc. filed its annual report, it did so as if the spin-off had not yet occurred. However, when HP Enterprise filed its inaugural annual report with the U.S. Securities and Exchange Commission, it provided revenue and warranty expense figures for just itself, for both fiscal 2015 and fiscal 2014.

What we're going to do is subtract one from the other, calculating the separate warranty expenses for a post-spin-off HP Inc. based on the known figures for HP Co. and HPE. In Figure 5 we're looking at the three entities' warranty claims totals for 2014 and 2015: the first and third columns are for HP Co., and the second and fourth columns are for the separated HP Inc. and HPE.


Figure 5
HP Inc. & HPE's Product Warranties
Claims Paid per Fiscal Year, 2014 to 2015
(in Millions of U.S. Dollars)

Figure 5


When the company split in two, roughly half the revenue went to each new entity. However, a much higher share of the HP Inc. sales total was made up of warranted hardware. Therefore, even though each got half the revenue, HP Inc.'s share of the claims total turned out to be about three-quarters of the parent's claims total. In fact, in 2014 its share was 74%, rising to 76% in 2015.

The same goes for warranty accruals. Of the parent's $1.84 billion accrual total in 2014, more than 74% turned out to be HP Inc. while only 26% turned out to be HPE. In fiscal 2015, HP Inc.'s share rose to 75% of the total while HPE's share dropped to 25%. It's a simple reflection of the fact that laptops and printers are more warranty-intensive than servers or storage systems.


Figure 6
HP Inc. & HPE's Product Warranties
Accruals Made per Fiscal Year, 2014 to 2015
(in Millions of U.S. Dollars)

Figure 6


And it's much the same story for the split in warranty reserves. Of the $1.96 billion HP Co. held in warranty reserves as of October 2014, we reckon that about 71% went to HP Inc. while about 29% went to HPE. By October 2015, HP Inc.'s share of the $1.7 billion total had fallen to 69%, while HPE's total had risen slightly to 31%. Both company's reserve balance was down, but one's declined at a slightly slower pace.


Figure 7
HP Inc. & HPE's Product Warranties
Reserves Held per Fiscal Year, 2014 to 2015
(in Millions of U.S. Dollars)

Figure 7


HPE is still likely to remain a top 10 warranty provider in the U.S., ranked somewhere near Boeing and Navistar. But only 32% to 37% of its total revenue comes from warranted servers and systems, while 70% to 88% of HP Inc.'s total revenue comes from warranted PCs and printer hardware. And this causes the primary difference between the two new entities: not only does HP Inc. have higher warranty expenses than HPE, but it also pays them at a higher rate.

New Warranty Expense Rates

In Figure 8, we've taken the warranty expense totals from Figures 1, 2, 5 and 6 and compared them to the corresponding warranted hardware sales totals for each company. As noted, the HP Co. warranty expenses are compared to the HP Co. product revenue figures, as was done in Figure 4. The other two line pairs are a little different, because each company is now providing a more detailed segmentation of its product revenue.

For instance, HP Inc. now provides separate figures for printer consumables and hardware, which HP Co. did not. And HPE now provides separate figures for hardware and software, which HP Co. did not. As a result, the warranted product totals for HP Inc. and HPE aren't as high as they were for HP Co. This has a slight impact on HPE's warranty expense rates, and a somewhat more visible change on those of HP Inc.


Figure 8
HP Inc. & HPE's Product Warranties
Claims Paid & Accruals Made as a
Percentage of Product Revenue, 2014 to 2015
(in Percent)

Figure 8


For HPE, the net change is very small, with the newly-calculated 2014 data points being only .03% to .04% lower than the parent company's. However, keep in mind that the 2014 expense rates for HPE are merely theoretical, because the company didn't exist at the time. But if it had, its servers and storage systems would have had roughly the same warranty expense rates as the parent. In 2015, the difference is more noticeable, with HPE's warranty expense rates a third to a half a point lower than the former parent's.

Conversely, HP Inc. has much higher warranty expense rates than its former parent, as can be clearly seen in Figure 8. For these past two fiscal years, HP Inc's warranty expense rates have been running about 0.8% to a full percentage point higher than HP Co.'s rates did. But again, part of the reason for this difference is that HP Inc. is allowing us to subtract the consumables before making our calculations, while HP Co. did not.

However, as is the case when we looked at comparable companies such as Lexmark International Inc., the suspicion is that printer hardware alone has a very high warranty expense rate, because prices are kept low to retain customer loyalty. The profit is made on sales of ink and toner, which are consumable products.

Likewise, we've always found that the smaller the computer, the higher its warranty expense. Palm Inc., before being acquired by HP, had some very high warranty expense rates. Dollar for dollar, laptops have higher warranty expense rates than desktops, and desktops have higher rates than servers. So HP Inc. is at the high end of the scale with both its PCs and printer product lines. And the chart above proves it.

Tavant

 

This Week’s Warranty Week Headlines

Columnist's snowblower fails 8 days before extended warranty expires.
Harvard Post, Concord MA, February 18, 2016
Microsoft consolidates all European Lumia warranty repair to Hungary.
Win Beta, February 18, 2016
Select Home Warranty denies a claim for three different reasons.
WFTS-TV Tampa FL, February 18, 2016
Swash by Whirlpool uses Registria's Photoregister to connect with buyers.
Press Release, February 17, 2016
Chinese manufacturing warranties explained.
China Law Blog, February 17, 2016
 

More Warranty Headlines below



Mize Warranty Connect

 

Warranty Headlines (cont’d)

Fire chief who bought repair-prone fire trucks has job offer rescinded.
Fire Chief, February 17, 2016
Argosy Group closes, stops honoring warranty claims on its soft-serve machines.
Orlando Business Journal, February 17, 2016
New San Juan Island ferry springs a leak, warranty claim made.
KOMO-TV Seattle, February 16, 2016
Tesla raises prices, removes transferability from service contracts.
The Verge, February 14, 2016
Business technology equipment costs more because the warranties are longer.
Business 2 Community, February 14, 2016
 

More Warranty Headlines below



Warranty Chain Management Conference

 

Warranty Headlines (cont’d)

Apple facing lawsuit over "Error 53" iPhone 6 bricking.
Mac Rumors, February 11, 2016
Mazda extends warranty to fix melting dash boards.
WFTS-TV Tampa FL, February 11, 2016
Vehicle service contracts promote car dealership customer loyalty.
Wards Auto, February 11, 2016
Columnist's used Aston Martin gets $4,409 in warranty work in first month.
Jalopnik, February 10, 2016
GWC Warranty introduces new version of its website.
SubPrime Auto Finance News, February 10, 2016
 

More Warranty Headlines below



PCMI - Your technology partner

 

Warranty Headlines (cont’d)

American Home Shield shares 4 smart tips for consumers.
Press Release, February 10, 2016
Mandatory arbitration clauses make it hard for consumers to sue.
WFTV-TV Orlando FL, February 10, 2016
Assurant says growth in mobile and auto warranties offset by tablet program loss.
Press Release, February 9, 2016
The RoomStores of Phoenix goes bankrupt, won't honor warranties.
WFMY-TV Greensboro NC, February 9, 2016
Two men arrested for lightning rod warranty fraud.
Eau Claire (WI) Leader-Telegram, February 9, 2016
 

More Warranty Headlines below



After Warranty Analytics

 

Warranty Headlines (cont’d)

OneGuard Home Warranties wins Angie's List Super Service Award.
Press Release, February 8, 2016
Problem-plagued Fogo ferry not a lemon, says Damen Shipyards.
CBC News, February 8, 2016
Allison Transmission blames warranty expenses for profit drop.
Press Release, February 8, 2016
Freshfields criticised over ScottishPower PowerPlan warranty advice.
Global Legal Post, February 8, 2016
Top Scottish Power executives decline to give evidence to UK Parliament.
Scottish Daily Record, February 7, 2016
 

More Warranty Headlines below



Sign up for a free subscription to Warranty Week:
     subscribe     change of address     unsubscribe


 

Warranty Headlines (cont’d)

LG Electronics extends warranty to 10 years on appliances in Nigeria.
All Africa, February 5, 2016
Dronelife and New Leaf introduce service contracts specifically for drones.
Press Release, February 4, 2016
Continental Automotive says 5 million vehicles may have faulty air bags.
Reuters, February 4, 2016
New ferry's troubles raise questions about other two ferry's warranties.
VOCM News, St. John's, Newfoundland, February 4, 2016
Cell phone warranty complaints top Philippines DTI's list for 2015.
Cebu City Sun Star, February 4, 2016
 

More Warranty Headlines below



Entigo, Founding Sponsor

 

Warranty Headlines (cont’d)

For service contracts, is an ATV a motor vehicle or a consumer good?
Meenan P.A., February 3, 2016
Coast Guard pays to fix Huntington Ingalls cutters that warranties don't cover.
Miami Herald, February 3, 2016
Provincial ferry service replaced by air while warranty work proceeds.
CBC News, February 2, 2016
Rumor: Samsung Galaxy S7 to feature shattered screen replacement warranty?
Android Headlines, February 2, 2016
2-10 Home Buyers Warranty announces its top sales people for 2016.
Press Release, February 1, 2016
The Internet of Things may benefit warranty companies, research suggests.
Nearshore Americas, February 1, 2016
Boston commuter rail locomotive returned to GE for warranty work.
State House News Service, February 1, 2016
GSA selling used Black Hawk helicopter "as is," without warranty.
Federal Times, February 1, 2016
Car dealers in Qatar told to amend the terms of their warranties.
Gulf Times (Doha), February 1, 2016
How offering rustproofing services can help car care businesses expand.
Professional Carwashing & Detailing, February 1, 2016
Hyundai offers 7-year/200,000-km warranty in South Africa.
Independent Online (SA), February 1, 2016
Hanson Research lengthens lab instrument warranties from 1 to 3 years.
Press Release, February 1, 2016
GM & dealers settle FTC charges over unrepaired recalls on used cars.
Press Release, January 28, 2016
Warranty Solutions names Automotive Assurance Group as its top producer for 2015.
Press Release, January 27, 2016
Canadian Coast Guard makes warranty claims against Irving Shipbuilding.
CBC News, January 27, 2016
Some fake Apple stores close or switch brands in Shenzhen, China.
Reuters, January 27, 2016
Opal Auto Mart and EWP Services to merge and become Malaysia's largest extended warranty provider.
The Star (Malaysia), January 27, 2016
Circuit City to open retail outlets and online sales in June.
This Week in Consumer Electronics, January 26, 2016
Accuride's steel wheels warranted for 5 years against corrosion.
Press Release, January 26, 2016
LG Electronics says G4 rebooting is a hardware defect covered by warranty.
Phandroid, January 26, 2016
Fitbit scammers explain how they pulled off massive warranty fraud.
BuzzFeed News, January 26, 2016
Mitsubishi works with LGM Financial Services on CPO program in Canada.
Auto Remarketing Canada, January 26, 2016
Attorney Bob Brennan explains California's Lemon Law.
Hanford Sentinel (CA), January 23, 2016
Data suggests Apple's iPhone Upgrade Program has moved 250K units.
Apple Insider, January 22, 2016
How to dry out and fix a water-damaged iPhone or iPad.
Macworld UK, January 22, 2016
CFPB alleges unlawful lending practices against Herbies Auto Sales.
Consent Order, January 21, 2016
Asurion sign removed from now-closed facility in Great Falls MT.
Great Falls Tribune, January 21, 2016
Warranteer launches warranty tracking app for mobile phones in India.
CNN-IBN, January 21, 2016
Warranteer's e-warranty solution helps identify authenticity of deals and dealers.
Economic Times (India), January 21, 2016
JC Penney to test re-entry into the major appliance business.
Forbes, January 20, 2016
Kroll Ontrack predicts more demand for Apple data recovery services in 2016.
Channel Biz, January 20, 2016
Bobcat telehandlers made in France get a 3-year warranty.
Materials Handling World (UK), January 20, 2016
Federal Trade Commission hosts daylong workshop on automotive retailing.
Automotive News, January 19, 2016
VW tries to block lemon law hearing in Florida over diesel cheating scandal.
WPTV-TV West Palm Beach FL, January 19, 2016
New home warranty law comes into force in Manitoba Jan. 1, 2017.
Press Release, January 19, 2016
When does it make sense to buy an extended warranty?
Bangor Daily News, January 18, 2016
Warranty Direct says potholes cause 1/10th of mechanical failures on British roads.
The Telegraph (UK), January 18, 2016
Could Hyundai Motor America offer lifetime warranties or lifetime service?
Automotive News, January 18, 2016
Dick Smith details which extended warranties remain valid during its bankruptcy.
National Business Review (NZ), January 16, 2016
AmTrust Financial Services announces 2-for-1 stock split.
Press Release, January 15, 2016
HomeWarrantyReviews.com announces 2016 Annual Home Warranty Award winners.
Press Release, January 15, 2016
Optronics expands its lifetime warranty to its entire LED lamp catalog.
Press Release, January 14, 2016
Best Buy reports declining extended warranty attach rates and claims costs.
Press Release, January 14, 2016
Paul Newton takes over as new CEO of Car Care Plan.
Car Dealer Magazine (UK), January 14, 2016
Two Chicago dealerships allege FCA offered them money to falsify sales.
Fortune, January 14, 2016
 

More Warranty Headlines